Flagship 2024 – Day 1 is live! Click here to register and watch now.

Homegrown Versus SaaS Feature Toggle Solutions

Contents

Feature toggle solutions are becoming increasingly popular among developers and product teams. They enable rapid deployment of features, testing in production environments, and easy rollback or disablement when needed. But what is the best option for your project: a homegrown feature toggle solution or a software-as-a-service (SaaS) feature toggle? In this article, we’ll explore the advantages and disadvantages of both approaches so you can make an informed decision on which one best suits your needs.

Overview of Feature Toggles in Start-Up and Enterprise Environments

Feature toggles bring great value to both enterprise businesses and startups, allowing developers and product teams to deploy features quickly, test them in production, and easily roll them back or disable them when needed.

For enterprises, feature toggles provide a way to continuously deliver new features while maintaining the stability of existing code. They allow teams to break down large projects into smaller releases that can be completed independently without the need for complete platform redeployment every time a feature is added or updated. By using feature toggles, enterprises can reduce downtime associated with more traditional deployment methods, allowing for greater customer satisfaction through faster delivery of new features.

For startups, feature toggles provide an incredibly powerful tool for testing different versions of software components in production environments without risking user experience. With the ability to rapidly deploy and test different variations of software components in production environments, startups can rapidly iterate on ideas without having to spend extensive amounts of time and resources on development cycles. This allows them to gain valuable insights into customer behavior and preferences at a fraction of the cost associated with traditional development cycles.

Advantages of Homegrown Feature Toggle Solutions

Homegrown feature toggle solutions offer many advantages for developers and product teams. The first and most obvious benefit is customization: With a homegrown solution, you have full control over the feature toggle logic and can tailor it to your specific needs. This allows you to fine-tune your feature toggle strategy, enabling you to react quickly to customer feedback or changing market dynamics without having to wait for an external solution.

Another advantage is cost savings. By developing your own feature toggle infrastructure, you can avoid expensive SaaS subscription costs associated with third-party solutions.

Additionally, you don’t need to worry about vendor lock-in or compatibility issues that are possible when integrating a third-party solution into existing systems.

Finally, homegrown feature toggle solutions allow for greater flexibility in terms of scalability and reliability. With the ability to customize every aspect of the feature toggle system, teams can ensure that performance meets their exact requirements regardless of how many features are deployed at any given time. Keep in mind: Home grown solutions aren’t nearly as scalable as SAAS solutions. When scaling to fit growing initiatives, it can become a costly endeavor pretty quick. 

Disadvantages of Homegrown Feature Toggle Solutions

Despite the numerous pros offered by homegrown feature toggle solutions, there are also some drawbacks that should be taken into consideration before investing in this type of system. The greatest disadvantage is time investment: Creating a custom feature toggle system requires significant upfront development effort as well as ongoing maintenance to keep up with changes in codebases or product offerings.

Additionally, with a custom system, there is no guarantee that errors or bugs will be caught right away due to lack of testing resources or expertise available outside the team. This could lead to costly downtime or unexpected behaviors when deploying new features if not mitigated properly ahead of time through comprehensive testing processes before release.

Lastly, while homegrown systems may have lower initial costs than SaaS solutions, they could become more expensive over time due to heavy reliance on internal resources instead of leveraging externally managed services provided by SaaS vendors.

Advantages of SaaS Feature Toggle Solutions

The primary advantage of using a SaaS feature toggle solution is the speed and convenience of deployment. With a SaaS offering, teams can quickly configure and deploy features with minimal effort and without having to worry about the creation and ongoing maintenance of the feature toggling system itself. This allows organizations to rapidly test different variations of products or services in production environments right away, which can provide invaluable insights into customer behavior and preferences.

Another benefit of SaaS solutions is that they are typically backed by a team of services experts that can help organizations troubleshoot any issues that may arise during the feature toggle process. This can save teams time and money as they don’t have to invest in recruiting or training personnel for such tasks. Additionally, with a managed service solution, teams can rest assured that their feature toggle infrastructure is always up to date with the latest technologies.

Finally, many SaaS feature toggle solutions offer flexible pricing models that make it easier for companies to scale up or down based on their specific needs. This provides companies with an affordable solution for testing out new ideas without breaking the bank or investing too much upfront cost into the venture.

Disadvantages of SaaS Feature Toggle Solutions

Despite all the advantages offered by SaaS feature toggle solutions, there are also some drawbacks that should be taken into consideration when deciding if this type of system is right for you. The primary disadvantage is vendor lock-in: Since most SaaS solutions use proprietary code bases, it can be difficult to switch vendors after investment has been made in development cycles or data pipeline capabilities. Additionally, teams may find it difficult to customize certain aspects of their environment if not supported by the third-party vendor’s API or SDK offerings.

Additionally, due to its reliance on external resources for maintenance and support, a SaaS feature toggle solution can become expensive over time depending on usage levels and product requirements—as well as exchange rates if multiple currencies are involved in billing transactions. 

Finally, some SaaS vendors have been known to have hidden costs associated with certain features so it’s important for organizations to carefully review any contracts before signing up for services to avoid unexpected expenses down the line.

Comparison Between Homegrown vs. SaaS Feature Toggle Solutions

The comparison between homegrown and SaaS feature toggle solutions comes down to flexibility, cost and ease of use.

Homegrown solutions offer more flexibility in terms of customizing the feature toggle process according to the team’s specific needs. Additionally, teams can create their own tooling to enable rapid iteration or experiment with new features without relying on third-party services. 

However, this also means that teams are responsible for any maintenance required to keep up with changes in codebases or product offerings. Additionally, with a custom system, there is no guarantee that errors or bugs will be caught right away due to lack of testing resources or expertise available outside the team. This could lead to costly downtime or unexpected behaviors when deploying new features if not mitigated properly ahead of time through comprehensive testing processes before release. Lastly, while homegrown systems may have lower initial costs than SaaS solutions for simple use cases, they could become more expensive over time due to heavy reliance on internal resources instead of leveraging externally managed services provided by SaaS vendors.

On the other hand, SaaS feature toggle solutions offer greater speed and convenience when it comes to deployment and configuration since teams don’t have to worry about ongoing maintenance tasks themselves. Additionally, these solutions are typically backed by a team of services experts that can help organizations troubleshoot any issues that may arise during the feature toggle process. Furthermore, many SaaS feature toggle solutions offer flexible pricing models that make it easier for companies to scale up or down based on their specific needs. 

Despite all these advantages, however, SaaS solutions may involve vendor lock-in, where teams find it difficult to switch vendors after investment has been made in development cycles or data processing capabilities, as well as hidden costs associated with certain features that can lead to unexpected expenses down the line.

No matter what, it is important for teams to carefully evaluate all options before making any decisions so they can ensure they are making an informed choice based on their unique context.

What to Consider When Choosing a Solution for Your Project

When choosing a solution for your project, there are several factors to consider to ensure you select the best option for your needs. First, it is important to evaluate if the feature toggle solution offered can meet the technical requirements of the project as well as any scalability and performance demands. This means confirming that the vendor’s API or SDK offerings can be integrated with existing systems and frameworks or if additional resources need to be acquired to enable integration.

Additionally, teams should carefully consider any cost implications associated with each solution since homegrown solutions may require a greater investment in terms of internal resources, while SaaS solutions could become more expensive over time due to usage levels and product requirements.

Furthermore, organizations should also factor in any potential vendor lock-in risks when selecting a SaaS solution which could make it difficult for them to switch vendors after high levels of investment have already been made in development cycles or data pipeline integrations.

Finally, teams should also evaluate their own expertise when selecting a feature toggle solution since homegrown systems may require additional skills or experience that may not be available internally, while SaaS solutions provide always available external support from managed services experts who could prove invaluable during the feature toggle process.

Examples of Successful Implementations With Homegrown or SaaS Feature Toggles

One example of successful implementations with homegrown feature toggles occurred at a large retailer where the company was able to provide an enhanced user experience by creating a customized feature toggle system that allowed them to quickly roll out new features and test them in production without disrupting live users. This enabled their development team to rapidly deploy features, experiment, and iterate on them quickly and easily without having to worry about manual deployments.

Additionally, by leveraging their existing internal resources as well as optimizing the system for scalability, they were able to optimize their cost investment and maximize usability while still delivering a high-quality user experience.

Another example of successful implementations with SaaS feature toggles can be seen at a major multinational telecommunications company. By using an established SaaS solution, the company was able to quickly roll out new products and features across its global customer base without any disruption or downtime. Furthermore, thanks to the support provided by managed services experts, the team was also able to troubleshoot any issues that arose during the process quickly and efficiently, allowing them to focus on innovative product development rather than having to spend time on technical maintenance tasks. In addition, the flexible pricing model offered by the vendor enabled the company to scale up or down based on their specific needs while avoiding unexpected costs associated with certain features.

Switch It On With Split

The Split Feature Data Platform™ gives you the confidence to move fast without breaking things. Set up feature flags and safely deploy to production, controlling who sees which features and when. Connect every flag to contextual data, so you can know if your features are making things better or worse and act without hesitation. Effortlessly conduct feature experiments like A/B tests without slowing down. Whether you’re looking to increase your releases, to decrease your MTTR, or to ignite your dev team without burning them out–Split is both a feature management platform and partnership to revolutionize the way the work gets done. Schedule a demo to learn more.

Get Split Certified

Split Arcade includes product explainer videos, clickable product tutorials, manipulatable code examples, and interactive challenges.

Want to Dive Deeper?

We have a lot to explore that can help you understand feature flags. Learn more about benefits, use cases, and real world applications that you can try.

Create Impact With Everything You Build

We’re excited to accompany you on your journey as you build faster, release safer, and launch impactful products.